Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Those essays are available for free on his site. If you want to scrap it for yourself, you're in a grey zone, but it will be fine. But hey, authors deserve respect : if an author wants to publish an ebook, he will.


Why am I in a grey zone for manipulating a bunch of bytes that I have downloaded into a format I find convenient?

The bytes were distributed legally by the copyright holder.

I downloaded the bytes legally using an ISP that I paid for.

The author did not use a robots.txt indicating his wishes that I not download the bytes using an automatic tool.

The bytes are unprotected by DRM.

I have no intention to distribute the bytes to anyone else.

I have not broken the DRM on my ebook reader.


You can scrap for yourself (or in Instapaper, but that's another story), but sharing a script and telling the others to do so is bad.

Call me old fashioned, but I'm thinking that an author has his word to say on the way to structure and distribute his works.


Scraping content isn't bad if you aren't redistributing it, technically your web browser is scraping content in the same sense.

http://paulgraham.com/robots.txt doesn't disallow robots from reading the essays.


Let's not be naïve. This is geek-clad redistribution.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: