Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is example comes from dubious

Utterly irrelevant, though this is the copy/paste regurgitated reply whenever it's mentioned.

Go yell fire in a theater right now. You will be hit with a variety of fun charges. Just as you have absolutely no right to announce threats against other persons, most defended being the president or any other politician.

All speech has limits.

Because speech has worldly consequences.



> Go yell fire in a theater right now. You will be charge with a variety of fun charges.

Most likely, you'll just be thrown out of the theater.

If you actually dircectly provoke a riot by doing that, then you'll be subject to criminal sanction. Without inciting imminent lawless action, it's protected speech.

> All speech has limits.

Free speech has limits, but the “fire in a crowded theater” example (and the “clear and present danger” rule it came along with) is not an valid example of the limits (or the operative rule).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: